AI Analysis:
This message mentions Kelsi Smith in the subject line and discusses her in the original message thread. The user's real question asks for ALL messages from expert 'smith', and while this message is not FROM Kelsi Smith, it clearly mentions her and discusses her work providing medical reports. This satisfies the criteria for relevance as it mentions the expert 'smith' that the user is seeking information about.
"Joann Attard-Helvig" Date: December 02, 2025 2:51:00 PM Subject: Re: San Jose chiro panel - Kelsi Smith- Nicolas Borovsky or Dana Robinson Reply to list Reply to sender Print List: lawnet Sent By: Joann Attard-Helvig Reply To Sender Reply To List Search Settings Hi everyone, I received additional info on Borovsky. He is with Sharp Medical Evaluators and they tend to do a good job in general. If he ends up being the Panel doc, I'll follow up with more info. Thank you, Joanne Helvig -----Original Message----- From: maddogbab@aol.com Sent: November 14, 2025 1:22:00 PM To: lawnet@lists.trialsmith.com Subject: Re: San Jose chiro panel - Kelsi Smith- Nicolas Borovsky or Dana Robinson All unknown to me. Mad Dog On Friday, November 14, 2025 at 11:15:41 AM PST, Joann Attard-Helvig (lawnet listserver) <listsender-lawnet@lawnet.caaa.org> wrote: ' List: lawnet Sent By: Joann Attard-Helvig ' ' Reply To Sender ' Reply To List ' Search ' Settings ' Hi listmates, I received this Chiro panel of largely Unknown's. Someone had mentioned that Kelsi Smith gave them two good initial reports, but I don't see any mention of final reports. Does anyone have any experience with these doctors? Did anyone receive a final report from Dr. Smith yet? Thank you! Joanne Helvig
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding ALL messages from expert 'smith'. While the message mentions 'Dr. Meredith B Smith Ph.D.' in the original inquiry being responded to, this message is FROM 'Nooshin Dalili', not from someone named 'smith'. The user specifically wants messages authored by someone with the surname 'smith', and this message fails to meet that criteria as it's written by a different person entirely.
"Nooshin Dalili" Date: January 19, 2026 3:15:00 PM Subject: Re: Who to Strike Psych - McDonald, Smith or Yanez Reply to list Reply to sender Print List: lawnet Sent By: Nooshin Dalili Reply To Sender Reply To List Search Settings I've had one report from Dr. McDonald for a security guard who was assaulted by an assailant and developed PTSD. He provided a GAF of 59 /17% WPI, which was Okay, and he was supportive of ongoing treatment. I would not strike him. Nooshin Dalili SJO -----Original Message----- From: sellnout@yahoo.com Sent: January 16, 2026 1:03:00 PM To: lawnet@lists.trialsmith.com Subject: Who to Strike Psych - McDonald, Smith or Yanez Who to strike for client with failed back and need for therapy as consequence of industrial injury. Bobbie L McDonald Psy. DMeredith B Smith Ph.D.Muriel Yanez, Psy.D Steve FosterSiles & Foster, P.C.Chico, CA
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding ALL messages from expert 'smith'. The message is from 'Steve Foster', not from anyone named 'smith'. While the message mentions 'Smith' as one of three options to strike for a psych evaluation (McDonald, Smith or Yanez), this appears to be referring to medical professionals rather than the message author. Since the user specifically wants messages FROM expert 'smith', and this message is from a different author, it is not relevant to their request.
Who to strike for client with failed back and need for therapy as consequence of industrial injury.
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding ALL messages from expert 'smith'. While the message discusses 'Dr. Kelsi Smith, DC', it is authored by Nooshin Dalili, not by someone named 'smith'. The user is specifically looking for messages FROM a person named 'smith', and this message is from a different author discussing someone else named Smith. The author name 'Nooshin Dalili' does not match the requested expert 'smith'.
"Nooshin Dalili" Date: January 15, 2026 1:38:00 PM Subject: Re: Anything new on Kelsi Smith or Michael Rosson, DC? Reply to list Reply to sender Print List: lawnet Sent By: Nooshin Dalili Reply To Sender Reply To List Search Settings Update on Dr. Kelsi Smith, DC: I received a final report from her. She provided reasonable/Ok permanent disability ratings for the lumbar and cervical spine based on DRE, and for the shoulders based on range of motion. The report does not include a pain rating or any discussion of Kite. Apportionment was 100% industrial and she was very generous on future medical. Overall, it is a reasonable report, though it could have been stronger. Based on this experience, I would not strike her, but she would not necessarily be my first choice. Nooshin Dalili SJO -----Original Message----- From: nooshin@dalililaw.com Sent: February 22, 2024 6:50:00 PM To: lawnet@lists.trialsmith.com Subject: Anything new on Kelsi Smith or Michael Rosson, DC? Hi all, I have a panel with 2 unknown DC QMEs, Dr. Smith and Dr. Rosson. According to prior posts, they were both unknown as of few months ago. Has anyone received a report from them in the last few months? Any updates on the prior comments? Thank you, Nooshin Dalili SJO
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding messages from 'smith'. The message is from 'Tim W. English', not from anyone named 'smith'. While the subject line mentions 'Smith' as one of three experts being discussed for striking in a psychological evaluation context, this is merely mentioning the name rather than being a message FROM Smith. Since the user specifically wants messages FROM the expert Smith, and this message is from a different person (Tim W. English), it does not meet the criteria for relevance.
Tim W. English, Esq. Founding Shareholder Wiesner English, P.C. 1660 Hamilton Ave., STE 206 San Jose, CA 95125 TEL: (408) 889-5598 FAX: (408) 889-1813 tim@weworkinjury.com AVVO Profile ** PLEASE NOTE OUR NEW SUITE NUMBER - 206 ** If you or your family have suffered loss due to a work injury and have a child in or applying for college, please click here to learn about Kids' Chance scholarship opportunities . LEGAL NOTICE: This email contains privileged, confidential information only for the intended recipient. If you received in error, any dissemination, distribution or copy of this email message, contents, or attachments is strictly prohibited. If you received this message in error, please notify us by email then destroy any copies you possess. Until and unless an attorney-client agreement has been mutually executed by sender and recipient, no information contained in this email shall constitute legal advice.
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding messages from expert 'smith'. The message is from Philip McGuire, not from anyone named Smith. The user specifically requested ALL messages from a person named 'smith', and since this message is from a different author (Philip McGuire), it does not meet the criteria for relevance to the real question.
Thanks Hollie. Phil McGuire.
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding ALL messages from expert 'smith'. The message is from 'Diep Nguyen', not from anyone named 'smith'. Since the user is specifically looking for messages from a person named 'smith', and this message is from a different person entirely, it is not relevant to their request.
Diep Nguyen, Attorney At Law
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding messages from 'smith'. The message is from 'M. Hollie Rutkowski', not from anyone named 'smith'. Since the user is specifically looking for messages from a person named 'smith', and this message is from a different author entirely, it is not relevant to their request.
Thank you Leslie. Would you kind enough to send me these two cases.
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding messages from 'smith'. The message is from 'M. Hollie Rutkowski', not from anyone named 'smith'. The author's name does not contain 'smith' as either a first or last name, so it does not match the requested expert.
Thank you Leslie. Would you kind enough to send me these two cases.
AI Analysis:
This message does not help answer the user's question about finding messages from 'smith'. The message is from 'M. Hollie Rutkowski', not from anyone named 'smith'. The author's name does not contain 'smith' in any form, so this message does not match the criteria of being from the requested expert.
Thank you Bob. Phil McGuire.